In the Jewish sources, milk (chalav) is discussed generally but also in relation to the laws prohibiting the mixing meat and milk and in the description of Israel as a "land flowing with milk and honey."
Notable Sources
All Sources
A
A Holy People and Their Dietary Laws
TANAKH
The prohibition against boiling a young goat in its mother's milk emphasizes the Israelites' commitment to God and their unique dietary laws. This commandment, found in Deuteronomy, highlights compassion and holiness, key principles reflected in various dietary restrictions.
The Mocked Law
TANAKH
The prohibition of eating meat and milk together is often seen as irrational and superstitious by outsiders, even mocked by Satan and the nations of the world. Rabbi Jonathan Sacks explores the concept of 'ḥukkim,' Jewish laws that are considered beyond human reasoning, and contrasts them with other types of laws in Judaism.
The Permissibility of Human Milk
TALMUD
Jewish law makes a distinction between milk that has been removed from a woman's body and nursing directly from her. The Talmudic tractate Ketubot discusses the permissibility of human milk once it has been removed from the body, while prohibiting nursing directly from a woman for anyone other than a very young child.
The Three Covenants and the Prohibition of Milk
MIDRASH
The prohibition of cooking a kid in its mother's milk is intricately linked to three pivotal covenants between God and Israel. Explored in the Sifrei Devarim, a second-century halakhic midrash, this prohibition is connected to the covenants established at Chorev, Arvoth Moav, and Mount Gerizim and Mount Eival.
The Separation of Meat and Milk
TOSEFTA
The detailed regulations regarding the separation of meat and milk are fundamental to understanding Jewish dietary laws. The Tosefta, a late 2nd-century compilation of Jewish oral law, elaborates on the prohibition of mixing meat and milk, including distinctions between different types of meat and various dining scenarios.
A Practical Approach to Chalav Yisrael
HALAKHAH
For those who observe chalav yisrael, there is a practical leniency regarding powdered milk, especially useful for travelers and in certain dairy products. Rabbi Chaim Jachter discusses the halakhic (Jewish legal) perspectives on the use of non-chalav yisrael powdered milk, providing a practical approach for modern observance.
The Debate Over Chicken and Milk
COMMENTARY
Rabbi Yose HaGalili's leniency in permitting chicken with milk contrasts with the general rabbinic prohibition, highlighting the complexities in rabbinic law. Maimonides discusses the rabbinic ordinances, including the prohibition of mixing chicken with milk to prevent confusion with the Torah prohibition of mixing meat and milk.
Modern Perspectives on Chalav Yisrael
HALAKHAH
Rav Soloveitchik's leniency on non-Chalav Yisrael milk offers a modern perspective on kashrut laws, making it relevant for contemporary Jewish practice. Rabbi Chaim Jachter's analysis in Gray Matter contrasts Rav Soloveitchik's lenient stance with Rav Moshe Feinstein's stricter interpretation, providing a comprehensive understanding of this halakhic debate.
The Chalav Yisrael Debate
HALAKHAH
The necessity of Jewish supervision for milk (chalav yisrael) in light of modern regulations is a topic of significant debate within the Orthodox community. Rabbi Chaim Jachter explores the halakhic (Jewish legal) perspectives on whether contemporary regulations adequately ensure the kosher status of milk without Jewish supervision.
Meat and Dairy Rules
MISHNAH
The Mishnah provides detailed guidance on the prohibition of cooking meat in milk, including specific exceptions and distinctions made by early rabbinic authorities. This foundational Jewish legal text, compiled around 200 CE, discusses the laws of kashrut, particularly the prohibition against cooking meat and milk together.
The Purity of Milk
HALAKHAH
The strict prohibition against consuming dairy products from gentiles underscores the importance of maintaining dietary purity in Jewish tradition. In his monumental 12th-century legal code, the Mishneh Torah, Rambam discusses the necessity of Jewish supervision to ensure that milk is not mixed with non-kosher substances.
Meat and Dairy Rules
GUIDES
The separation of meat and milk is a cornerstone of Jewish dietary laws, with intricate rabbinic decrees to prevent accidental mixing. Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz explores the detailed customs and waiting periods established to ensure the separation of meat and milk.
From Cheese to Meat
HALAKHAH
The guidelines for transitioning from eating cheese to eating meat are detailed and specific, highlighting the importance of waiting periods and cleanliness. The Kitzur Shulchan Arukh, a 19th-century condensed code of Jewish law, provides practical guidelines for daily Jewish life, including the separation of dairy and meat.
The Value of Goat's Milk
TANAKH
Goat's milk was a vital source of sustenance and economic stability in ancient times. Proverbs 27:26-27 highlights the importance of goat's milk for food and household maintenance, emphasizing its sufficiency for sustenance.
A woman in traditional Yemeni dress kneels to milk a goat, 1920-1930. From the Yechiel Zehavi collection, the Ben-Zvi Institute
A woman in traditional Yemeni dress kneels to milk a goat, 1920-1930. From the Yechiel Zehavi collection, the Ben-Zvi Institute
We use cookies to give you the best experience possible on our site. Click OK to continue using Sefaria. Learn More.OKאנחנו משתמשים ב"עוגיות" כדי לתת למשתמשים את חוויית השימוש הטובה ביותר.קראו עוד בנושאלחצו כאן לאישור